Dining

Restaurants in Cooperstown, NY

Our Inn is conveniently located near, some within walking distance of, many restaurants in Cooperstown, NY. Guests will find a variety of dining options including, Italian cuisine, pizza, burgers, bakeries, plus local groceries and markets. Upon check-in, a guide to takeout and delivery dining options will be provided to each guest.

Important notes:
⦁ Reservations highly recommended for dinner as most dine-in restaurants are operating with limited capacity.
⦁ Hours of operation for each business as listed are subject to change by the individual business at any time.
⦁ Menus for most restaurants can be found on their website.
⦁ Many, but not all, businesses are within walking distance from the inn. Check with our front desk team for directions.
⦁ If you are planning to enjoy your food/beverage at the inn we can supply table settings, glassware, openers.
⦁ If you are looking for an outdoor setting to “picnic” the inn’s front porch is a great spot. In addition, there are benches and picnic tables at Lake Front Park.

Groceries / Markets

Spurbeck’s Grocery
Mon-Fri 8am – 6pm, Sat 8am – 3 pm
607.547.8681

Fly Creek Cider Mill
Mon-Sun 10am – 5:30pm
In Store Shopping plus
Online Ordering and Curbside Pick-up
607.547.9692

Cooperstown Farmers Market
Tues 12pm – 5pm, Sat 9am – 2pm
607.547.6195

Price Chopper Supermarket
Mon-Sun 7am – 10pm
Senior (60+) / Disabled 6am – 7am
607.547.2527

Tops Supermarket
Mon-Sun 6am – 10am
607.547.5956

Coffee / Sandwiches / Pizza

Stagecoach Coffee*
Mon-Sun 6:30am – 4pm
Take-out, Delivery, and Outdoor Dining
607.547.6229

Spurbeck’s Grocery*
Mon-Fri 8am – 6pm, Sat 8am – 3pm
Take-out
607.547.8681

Danny’s Market*
Mon-Sun 8am – 5pm
Take-out and Delivery
607.547.4053

Scheider’s Bakery*
Mon-Sat 6:30am – 3:30pm,
Sun 7:30am – 3pm
Take-out
607.547.9631

New York Pizzeria
Mon-Sun 11am – 9pm
Take-out and Delivery
607.547.2930

Sal’s Pizzeria
Sun, Wed, Thurs 11am – 6pm,
Fri-Sat 11am – 7pm
Take-out
607.547.5721

  • Breakfast sandwiches and/or breakfast
    items available at these businesses.

Restaurants

Mel’s at 22
Sun-Mon-Weds 11am-8pm, Closed Tues
Fri-Sat 12pm – 9pm
Take-out, Indoor and Outdoor Dining
607.322.4012

Alex’s World Bistro
Mon-Sun, Order between 3pm – 7pm
Pick up from 4pm – 8pm, Take-out Only
607.547.4070

Nicoletta’s Italian Cafe
Mon-Sun 4pm – 8pm
Take-out, Indoor and Outdoor Dining 607.547.7499

Toscana
Mon-Sun 4pm – 9pm
Take-out and Indoor Dining
607.547.2100

Bocca Osteria
Mon-Sun 3pm – 8pm
Take-out, Indoor and Outdoor Dining 607.282.4031

Council Rock Brewery
Take-out, Indoor and Outdoor Dining Take-out
607.643.3016

Double Day Cafe
Mon-Sun 7am – 8pm
Take-out and Indoor Dining
607.547.5468

Origins Café
Weds-Sat 11am – 4pm, Sun 10am – 3pm
Take-out, Indoor and Outdoor Dining
607.437.2862