Book Online Book Online


Dining in Cooperstown

Browse our suggested recommendations of our favorite restaurants in Cooperstown, NY.

Restaurants within a short walk from The Inn at Cooperstown:

  • Coopertown’s Farmer’s Market – This year-round market offers produce, pasture-raised meats, homemade bread, free range eggs, and so much more from over thirty growers, all located within 50 miles of town. Located at 101 Main St., in Pioneer Alley.
  • Mel's at 22 – Classic American food perfect for lunch or dinner. Located at 22 Chestnut St.
  • Alex's Bistro – Tastes and eats from around the world. Lunch, dinner, and Sunday brunch available. Located at 149 Main St.
  • Nicoletta’s Italian Café – Excellent Italian cuisine in a casual family dining setting. Located at 96 Main St.
  • Toscana Italian Grill – Great dinner atmosphere for Italian cuisine with a twist. Located at 64 Main St.
  • Hawkeye Grill –Serving a diverse lunch and dinner menu, plus the best burgers in town with views of Otsego Lake. Located at 60 Lake St.
  • Doubleday Café – Cozy casual cuisine with everything from salads and sandwiches to burgers and burritos. Located at 93 W. Main St.
  • New York Pizzeria - Classic New York style pizzeria with a warm family atmosphere. Ideal for lunch or dinner. Located at 75 Chestnut St.
  • Danny's Market –Casual market offering gourmet provisions, sandwiches, and freshly baked goods for over 20 years. Located at 92 Main St.
  • Stagecoach Coffee – Serving the best coffee and coffee drinks in town, they roast their own beans for the freshest flavor. The Inn at Cooperstown proudly serves Stagecoach coffee with our daily breakfast.

Restaurants within a short drive from The Inn at Cooperstown:

  • Blue Mingo Grill –Open seasonally, this lakeside grill is great for a casual lunch with their rotating, locally sourced American cuisine. Enjoy calming views of Otsego Lake with their lakeside location on the western shore.
  • Bocca Osteria – Enjoy delicious wood-fired Neapolitan Pizza at this family-owned Italian restaurant, open for lunch and dinner. Located at 5438 Chestnut St.
  • Cafe Ommegang –This local home-grown brewery serves up small bites, perfect for beer pairings. for a casual lunch or dinner. Located at 656 Co HWY 33
  • Council Rock Brew Pub -Enjoy casual bites such as sandwiches and burgers for lunch or dinner, paired with the perfect pale ale or oatmeal stout from their on-site brewery. Located at 4861 NY-28
  • Origins Cafe at Carefree Gardens – A food truck that serves up locally sourced fresh fare and thrives on giving back to the community. Home base is at the Carefree Gardens.
  • Fenimore Cafe at Fenimore Art Museum – Enjoy salad and wrap options for a tasty lunch on the terrace overlooking the garden grounds at the Fenimore Art Museum.
  • Upstate Bar and Grill – One of New York’s best Gastropubs brings savory dishes and local craft beer together at this casual restaurant. Serving lunch and dinner, they are located at 5418 NY-28.

Restaurants worth the drive:

  • The Rose and Kettle –Comfort food at its finest with an extensive wine list and crafty cocktails. Located in Cherry Valley, NY; about a 25-minute drive from the Inn.
  • The American Hotel – Located in nearby Sharon Springs, NY this fine dining establishment offers a fanciful brunch and a high-end lunch for those wanting a fine steak.
  • Black Cat Café – A casual lunch spot that serves great coffee, baked goods, and breakfast and lunch options. Located in Sharon Springs, NY, about 30 minutes from the Inn, this café is the perfect place to grab a picnic lunch for a day at Otsego Lake.
  • The Horned Dorset – This seasonal favorite in Leonardsville, NY serves up dinner with seafood, steaks, and lamb dishes, complimented with fresh produce from their own organic garden.
© 2019 . Internet Marketing & Design by RezStream.